Skip to content
Eval Suites50

Promptfoo vs. Inspect AI vs. DeepEval: Which Eval Harness Should You Pick?

Published Sources checked 3 min read · By the Eval Suites editors

At-a-glance answer (TL;DR)

Pick Promptfoo if you want YAML test files, fast prompt comparisons, and built-in red-teaming with a GitHub Action. Pick Inspect AI if you run agentic or research-grade evals that need sandboxes and a large library of ready-made benchmarks. Pick DeepEval if your team lives in pytest and wants named RAG and agent metrics out of the box. Plenty of teams run two of them.

The quick pick by team and workload

Choose by your team's main language and your riskiest failure, not by feature count. All three can score a prompt. They differ in where tests live and how they run.

Promptfoo, Inspect AI, and DeepEval compared on documented features
PromptfooInspect AIDeepEval
Primary interfaceYAML config + CLI (Node)Python tasks, solvers, scorers + CLIPython test cases run like pytest
MaintainerPromptfooUK AI Security InstituteConfident AI
Sandboxed tool useNot its focusDocker and other sandbox types per sampleNot its focus
Ready-made benchmarksFew; you write testsLarge public set in inspect_evalsSome benchmark loaders
Red-teamingBuilt-in red-team generatorVia safety evals in inspect_evalsSeparate project (DeepTeam)
CI storyOfficial GitHub Action with PR commentsCLI in any CI runnerdeepeval test run in CI

Sources for the table: Promptfoo docs on configuration, red-teaming, and the GitHub Action;[1][2][3] Inspect AI docs on scorers and sandboxing and the inspect_evals repository;[4][5][6] DeepEval's getting-started, metrics, and CI pages.[7][8][9]

When Promptfoo is the right harness

Promptfoo fits teams that want tests anyone can read in a pull request. You list prompts, providers, and test cases in YAML, then attach assertions such as contains, regex, is-json, or JavaScript functions.[10] It also supports model-graded checks like llm-rubric when nothing deterministic fits.[11]

Promptfoo tool-call check
# promptfooconfig.yaml
prompts:
  - file://prompts/support.txt
providers:
  - openai:gpt-4.1-mini
tests:
  - vars: { question: "Cancel my order 1042" }
    assert:
      - type: is-json
      - type: javascript
        value: JSON.parse(output).tool === 'cancel_order'

The catch: long, multi-step agent runs inside a real sandbox aren't what it's built around. You can call your own agent as a custom provider, but you'll write that glue yourself.

When Inspect AI is the right harness

Inspect AI fits agentic and safety work where the agent needs a real environment. Each sample can run in its own sandbox, and the docs cover Docker as a built-in option.[5] Scorers range from exact match to model-graded, and you can write your own in Python.[12]

Its biggest practical advantage is the inspect_evals collection: many published benchmarks, from coding to cyber to knowledge, already wired up as tasks.[6] If you need SWE-bench-style or capture-the-flag evals, starting there saves weeks.

Run a packaged benchmark with Inspect
pip install inspect-ai inspect-evals
inspect eval inspect_evals/gpqa_diamond --model openai/gpt-4.1 --limit 50

The cost is setup. Sandboxed evals need Docker on your runner, and Python is required.

When DeepEval is the right harness

DeepEval fits Python teams that want evals to feel like unit tests. You build test cases, attach metrics, and run them with deepeval test run, which slots into the CI you already have.[7][9] Its metric library covers RAG measures like faithfulness and contextual recall, plus G-Eval for custom rubric scoring.[8]

Most of those metrics use an LLM as the judge. That's convenient, but it means judge cost and judge drift become part of your test run. Read the guide on deterministic assertions before you let them block merges.

Can you use more than one harness?

Yes, and it's common. A typical split: Promptfoo for prompt regressions and red-team scans on every pull request, Inspect AI for nightly sandboxed agent and safety suites. What you shouldn't do is run the same tests in two harnesses and argue about which score is right.

Frequently asked questions

Suites mentioned in this guide

Related guides

Sources

  1. 1. Promptfoo: Intro · Promptfoo · Official docs · Sources checked
  2. 2. Promptfoo: LLM red teaming · Promptfoo · Official docs · Sources checked
  3. 3. Promptfoo: GitHub Action integration · Promptfoo · Official docs · Sources checked
  4. 4. Inspect AI documentation · UK AI Security Institute · Official docs · Sources checked
  5. 5. Inspect AI: Sandboxing · UK AI Security Institute · Official docs · Sources checked
  6. 6. inspect_evals repository · UK AI Security Institute (GitHub) · Repository · Sources checked
  7. 7. DeepEval: Getting started · Confident AI · Official docs · Sources checked
  8. 8. DeepEval: Metrics introduction · Confident AI · Official docs · Sources checked
  9. 9. DeepEval: Unit testing in CI/CD · Confident AI · Official docs · Sources checked
  10. 10. Promptfoo: Assertions and metrics · Promptfoo · Official docs · Sources checked
  11. 11. Promptfoo: Model-graded metrics · Promptfoo · Official docs · Sources checked
  12. 12. Inspect AI: Scorers · UK AI Security Institute · Official docs · Sources checked